Are cranks not supposed to go on all the way?

Related:
Create New Tag

Derek_Bolz

Vital BMX member Derek_Bolz
79998 Derek_Bolz http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/79998/avatar/c50_MAQ00457_1.jpg?1337467044 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/Derek-Bolz,79998/all 05/28/11 3 36 328 10 1

Posts: 364

Joined: 5/28/2011

Location: CAN

7/18/2014 2:59 PM

I just got new Cult OS cranks and no matter how hard I try, I can only get each crank about half way onto the spindle. I was using the biggest ratchet I had and pushing as hard as I could, and there were even metal shavings coming out, but they won't go on farther. Am I supposed to just put spacers in and leave them half way on?



"if you feel yourself falling backwards, thrust forward like you would if you were indeed fucking your bike, and if youre falling forwards, push your legs while leaning back, like if you were pulling out from fucking your bike But dont, under any circumstances, actually fuck your bike" - EddiMundo

dave lawrence

Vital BMX member dave lawrence
20481 dave lawrence http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/20481/avatar/c50_Skate_or_Leave_1466620531.jpg?1466620278 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/dave-lawrence,20481/all 05/23/08 94 39 1 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/dave-lawrence,20481/setup 232 17077 524 2 32

Posts: 17309

Joined: 5/23/2008

Location: Sartell, MN USA

Moderator

7/18/2014 3:13 PM

I would bet there is something preventing them from going further, like some weld spatter, or paint.

Contact the company?

Cranks should be able to go further than that.

I am sick and tired of the "cliques" that this sport has recently developed. We should embrace the fact that we all ride a little kids bike, and not worry about the small details. When you take riding in its most basic form, we are all the same.

Derek_Bolz

Vital BMX member Derek_Bolz
79998 Derek_Bolz http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/79998/avatar/c50_MAQ00457_1.jpg?1337467044 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/Derek-Bolz,79998/all 05/28/11 3 36 328 10 1

Posts: 364

Joined: 5/28/2011

Location: CAN

7/18/2014 4:09 PM

I somehow managed to tighten them so that there's about 1-2mm of space left, but I bent the 6mm hex socket I was using. I don't know what else to do, this is just ridiculous.

"if you feel yourself falling backwards, thrust forward like you would if you were indeed fucking your bike, and if youre falling forwards, push your legs while leaning back, like if you were pulling out from fucking your bike But dont, under any circumstances, actually fuck your bike" - EddiMundo

transition_chris

Vital BMX member transition_chris
109466 transition_chris http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/109466/avatar/c50_transition_fb_logo_1388275345.jpg?1388274353 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/transition-chris,109466/all 12/28/13 1 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/transition-chris,109466/setup 22 608

Posts: 630

Joined: 12/28/2013

Location: Edmonton, CAN

7/18/2014 4:10 PM

First of all, make sure you grease the crank arms and spindle well before installing your cranks.

If you've done that they should be able to pull on the rest of the way with the install tool. How big is the gap right now between your crank arms and your frame? (chainstays) Once a crank is properly installed you should have even distance on either side of your frame between the chainstay and the crank arm. Usually there is about a finger width between your crank and the frame.

Chris

www.bmxtransition.com
Canadian BMX Mailorder
Instagram: @transitionbmx

Derek_Bolz

Vital BMX member Derek_Bolz
79998 Derek_Bolz http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/79998/avatar/c50_MAQ00457_1.jpg?1337467044 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/Derek-Bolz,79998/all 05/28/11 3 36 328 10 1

Posts: 364

Joined: 5/28/2011

Location: CAN

7/18/2014 5:04 PM

Just like you said, there's about a finger width between the end of the crank arm and the chain stay on each side. However, there is still about 2mm of space showing on the spindle. And it isn't smooth spindle, either. It's splines. So I just don't understand why the crank won't go all the way on if there's still room on the splines.

"if you feel yourself falling backwards, thrust forward like you would if you were indeed fucking your bike, and if youre falling forwards, push your legs while leaning back, like if you were pulling out from fucking your bike But dont, under any circumstances, actually fuck your bike" - EddiMundo

pnj

Vital BMX member pnj
75953 pnj http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/75953/avatar/c50_pnj_duthie_064.jpg?1325215374 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/pnj,75953/all 02/24/11 14 962 4 2

Posts: 976

Joined: 2/24/2011

Location: Seattle, WA USA

7/18/2014 6:16 PM

This is why IMO longer run 48 spline cranks.

handlebar-to-face

Vital BMX member handlebar-to-face
103879 handlebar-to-face http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/103879/avatar/c50_s_m_gravity_400pix_1370722046.jpg?1370721875 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/handlebar-to-face,103879/all 03/12/13 1 101 4687 2

Posts: 4788

Joined: 3/12/2013

Location: Hawthorne, CA USA

7/18/2014 6:29 PM

Check the splines like dave said there maybe a bit of metal blocking them from going in all the way.


Also do you have any spacers on the opposite side?

THOU SHALL NOT COMMIT SKOOTERY
Murica bike check
REFS four, tomdon, bmx1995, jared42069, obiwan chromoly, hate breeder, nshs2010, asilva23, rascio,
Alfred NYC, Kymike, chuck8273(kind of), tc86, Ugot2dewitt, LLURider, dprc, ecuadevil, scramhype, Mario.villegas90(X2), dirtstars22, Brian_Griffin
text me323.245.2827

transition_chris

Vital BMX member transition_chris
109466 transition_chris http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/109466/avatar/c50_transition_fb_logo_1388275345.jpg?1388274353 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/transition-chris,109466/all 12/28/13 1 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/transition-chris,109466/setup 22 608

Posts: 630

Joined: 12/28/2013

Location: Edmonton, CAN

7/18/2014 10:35 PM

Derek_Bolz wrote:

Just like you said, there's about a finger width between the end of the crank arm and the chain stay on each side. However, there is still about 2mm of space showing on the spindle. And it isn't smooth spindle, either. It's splines. So I just don't understand why the crank won't go all the way on if there's still room on the splines.

The crank arms usually do not pull all the way on to the spindle - there is usually a bit of room left on the crank arms. With that said, it looks like you could got on a little further then just add a couple spacers.

Maybe try taking it apart, applying more grease and giving it another shot?

Chris

www.bmxtransition.com
Canadian BMX Mailorder
Instagram: @transitionbmx

bmxsteve99

Vital BMX member bmxsteve99
104707 bmxsteve99 http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/104707/avatar/c50_vital5.17.15_1431899110.jpg?1431899062 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/bmxsteve99,104707/all 04/14/13 82 3829 2 3

Posts: 3911

Joined: 4/14/2013

Location: Goleta, CA USA

7/19/2014 1:13 PM

if you didnt use grease thats your problem
are you using one of those crank tools?
check the spindles and arms for blockage in the spines

refs: hookjrclc, hardbmxtim, hatchmoses for sale and trade, kymike for sale and trade, blizzbikes for trade, and some other dude i cant remember his username, vrsapat956, colonydirt94, mario.villegas90, wolfen
Camera Setup: Panasonic HMC150, Panasonic GH2, Canon FTBn, Yashica Lynx 5000e, Canon 28mm f/2.8, Canon 50mm f1.4, Rokinon 7.5mm f/3.5

Mychaylo

Vital BMX member Mychaylo
108502 Mychaylo http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/108502/avatar/c50_DSC00130_1406740018.jpg?1406739408 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/Mychaylo,108502/all 10/21/13 6 1087 2 2

Posts: 1093

Joined: 10/21/2013

Location: GBR

7/19/2014 4:29 PM

I think the problem is that they arent primo.

dkTechEthan

Vital BMX member dkTechEthan
108982 dkTechEthan http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/108982/avatar/c50_008efedfd9d48d0c9e18e05903388357_1424155088.jpg?1424155074 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/dkTechEthan,108982/all 11/20/13 20 1 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/dkTechEthan,108982/setup 148 1311 9

Posts: 1459

Joined: 11/20/2013

Location: Manassas, VA USA

7/19/2014 4:42 PM

try taking them off and checking to see if their stripped or something, u can sometimes use like a pick to fix threading. then lightly grease it, it may help you get past any "rough" spots.

"The D.O.P.S. System"
DK, Odyssey, Profile, Shadow.
check out my bike check
@ethanbrackett
@powersbikeshop

blaaaaaaaaa

Vital BMX member blaaaaaaaaa
103921 blaaaaaaaaa http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/103921/avatar/c50_image_1443538790.jpg?1443538243 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/blaaaaaaaaa,103921/all 03/14/13 6 4 135 4031 5

Posts: 4166

Joined: 3/14/2013

Location: Richmond, VA USA

7/19/2014 5:31 PM

Mychaylo wrote:

I think the problem is that they arent primo.

Definitely

bike check

IG @curtis_cantbmxwell
@krusty_krew

Chuck8273

Vital BMX member Chuck8273
86726 Chuck8273 http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/86726/avatar/c50_image_1378092142.jpg?1378091187 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/Chuck8273,86726/all 11/03/11 14 15 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/Chuck8273,86726/setup 67 5735 11 2 10

Posts: 5802

Joined: 11/3/2011

Location: MO, USA

Moderator

7/19/2014 5:41 PM

When I received my chrome Fit indents, there was enough chrome plate build up in the splines to make them appear rounded. They wouldn't even start on the splines. About a half hour with a jewelers file and they were all fixed up. A bit tight going on, but I prefer it that way.

Refs: Tito24, RiverSideRider, Stussy, Nettyspaghetti, Daniel24, Freddydapice, BrokenBMX, SuperstarDK, HardBMX_Tim. There's more, but I'm too lazy to look them up, haha.

Mychaylo

Vital BMX member Mychaylo
108502 Mychaylo http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/108502/avatar/c50_DSC00130_1406740018.jpg?1406739408 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/Mychaylo,108502/all 10/21/13 6 1087 2 2

Posts: 1093

Joined: 10/21/2013

Location: GBR

7/19/2014 6:11 PM

Interesting note, a guy on here had a blob of weld on the spines of the crank arm, check, clean and grease.

dave lawrence

Vital BMX member dave lawrence
20481 dave lawrence http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/20481/avatar/c50_Skate_or_Leave_1466620531.jpg?1466620278 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/dave-lawrence,20481/all 05/23/08 94 39 1 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/dave-lawrence,20481/setup 232 17077 524 2 32

Posts: 17309

Joined: 5/23/2008

Location: Sartell, MN USA

Moderator

7/20/2014 6:58 AM

ALSO, to those saying "usually a finger width space" I wouldn't call that a rule of thumb, I leave a couple MM and that's it, reason being, I want enough spindle inside the crank arm, and it to clear the frame. Outside of that, I am good to go. Too much space outside means not enough spindle in many cases. I try to balance it nicely.

I am sick and tired of the "cliques" that this sport has recently developed. We should embrace the fact that we all ride a little kids bike, and not worry about the small details. When you take riding in its most basic form, we are all the same.

urebmx

Vital BMX member urebmx
112326 urebmx http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/112326/avatar/c50_DSC00468_1407247418.jpg?1407246711 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/urebmx,112326/all 07/20/14 3 99

Posts: 102

Joined: 7/20/2014

Location: Asheboro, NC USA

7/20/2014 7:46 AM

i agree with everyone saying there could be weld splatter on the spindle. however i am concerned with the amount of metal shavings coming out of the crank. not good....

i ride to stay young

dave lawrence

Vital BMX member dave lawrence
20481 dave lawrence http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/20481/avatar/c50_Skate_or_Leave_1466620531.jpg?1466620278 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/dave-lawrence,20481/all 05/23/08 94 39 1 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/dave-lawrence,20481/setup 232 17077 524 2 32

Posts: 17309

Joined: 5/23/2008

Location: Sartell, MN USA

Moderator

7/20/2014 7:51 AM

That's from the bolt being tightened too much

I am sick and tired of the "cliques" that this sport has recently developed. We should embrace the fact that we all ride a little kids bike, and not worry about the small details. When you take riding in its most basic form, we are all the same.

Derek_Bolz

Vital BMX member Derek_Bolz
79998 Derek_Bolz http://p.vitalbmx.com/photos/users/79998/avatar/c50_MAQ00457_1.jpg?1337467044 http://www.vitalbmx.com/community/Derek-Bolz,79998/all 05/28/11 3 36 328 10 1

Posts: 364

Joined: 5/28/2011

Location: CAN

7/22/2014 6:38 PM

Bit of extra pushing on it and I got them on. After checking the inside of the crank, I'm pretty sure there was some paint on the inside of them. Turns out the shavings were just from the back side of the spacer that goes around the bolt. Thanks for all the help everyone

"if you feel yourself falling backwards, thrust forward like you would if you were indeed fucking your bike, and if youre falling forwards, push your legs while leaning back, like if you were pulling out from fucking your bike But dont, under any circumstances, actually fuck your bike" - EddiMundo