When you said whipping out I thought you meant fakie tailwhip out, I guess that's a while off tho as your talking about Indians.
Sometimes it feels natural to Indian out but it won't help you in the long run & they look ugly so my suggestion is to learn switch 180s and learn to fakie out the right & left way, its what I did when I first started learning 180s cuz I was having the same issue as you, this way you get 2 tricks for the price of one.
Sounds like you could be a bit fuck footed but as long as your willing to learn things both ways it can be a major advantage, Learn everything regular & switch it the way to go bro.
Freestyle is the answer to everything --
a fresh way to approach a dull or a
dangerous thing.
to do a dull thing with style
is preferable to doing a dangerous thing
without it.
Os 94
Ms 01
Ns 12